Freelancers vs a Healthcare Software Development Company: What Changes When PHI Is Involved

TATEEDA publishes this article and sells one of the options compared here, the services of a healthcare software development company. TATEEDA’s healthcare page says it does not rely on freelancers or gig workers. That gives us a stake in this comparison, so check each source we link.

Hire a freelancer for a small, well-defined task where PHI is absent or one person can credibly meet the BAA and security duties. Consider a company when PHI, several roles, or a long roadmap are involved and you need one accountable party.

The difference shows up when PHI enters the project, because every person and tool that touches it becomes a contract, security, and continuity question. Healthcare software is our core specialty, and we also build custom software for other industries. Our healthcare software development services page describes what we do. This is general information, not legal advice, so have counsel review any contract.

Cost structure

Compare what each quote covers. A freelancer’s rate may cover one person’s time, while a company quote may include project management, QA, DevOps, and design. TATEEDA’s healthcare page lists development, QA, project management, UI/UX, DevOps, database, cloud, architecture, and API among the work its teams cover.

The IRS says it is critical that business owners correctly determine whether the people providing services are employees or independent contractors. It also says you generally do not have to withhold or pay taxes on payments to independent contractors (IRS guidance). If a worker is later reclassified as an employee, those obligations can apply. Get tax advice on classification before a freelancer works full time under your direction. Add your own management time and the cost of rework if the first engineer leaves.

PHI and BAA responsibility

HHS says a person, for business associate purposes, includes natural persons as well as organizations (HHS business associate guidance). Its examples of business associates include an independent medical transcriptionist and a health care app developer that handles patients’ PHI for a covered entity. A freelancer who creates, receives, maintains, or transmits PHI for you can fall inside the definition.

The regulations also describe workforce as people whose conduct, in the performance of work for a covered entity or business associate, is under its direct control, whether or not the entity pays them (federal regulation text). Whether a long-term contractor is workforce or a business associate depends on the facts, so ask counsel.

HHS says a business associate must have a BAA with its subcontractor before disclosing PHI, and it lists cloud service providers that store ePHI among its examples. Ask a freelancer whether they will sign a BAA, whether anyone else will touch the work, and which tools will hold PHI.

With a company, expect one BAA with one counterparty. Read it for a subcontractor list anyway.

Control and IP

The Copyright Office says the author is ordinarily the person who actually created the work, and that works made for hire are an exception (Copyright Office guidance). For commissioned work the exception needs four conditions, including a written agreement signed by all parties and one of nine eligible categories. The nine categories do not name custom software as such. Whether software fits one of them can be disputed, so do not count on it. If any condition fails, the work is not a work made for hire.

Do not rely on an informal agreement. Have counsel draft assignment terms before work starts, and require repository access, code review, and credential handover.

A company may put a manager between you and the engineers. TATEEDA’s healthcare FAQ says it can provide a dedicated project manager and adapt the management structure to the client’s preferred model. If you want people inside your own management structure instead, see IT staff augmentation vs outsourcing.

Continuity and the bus factor

The bus factor is the number of people who would have to leave before nobody understands the system. With one freelancer it is one. If your only developer takes another contract mid-project, work stops unless the code, documentation, and credentials are already in your hands.

A company may be able to reassign people. TATEEDA’s home page FAQ says it can replace a team member quickly when a project needs continuity or a different technical skill set. Verify that with references and contract terms.

Ramp-up time

Ask a freelancer for a start date in writing and confirm their current workload. Our guide to where to find developers for your business software projects covers the sourcing options.

TATEEDA’s healthcare FAQ says it can typically prepare a team to start quickly when the required specialists are available. It says the exact start date depends on scope, technologies, team composition, onboarding, system access, and contracts. Either way, finish the BAA and the access review before anyone touches PHI. For a wider staffing plan, see how to assemble a healthcare tech team.

Compliance work

The HHS risk analysis guidance says the scope covers ePHI in all forms of electronic media, such as hard drives and portable electronic media (HHS risk analysis guidance). Treat a freelancer’s laptop or phone as in scope if PHI could ever land on it, and agree on device rules in writing.

HHS also says a business associate is directly liable for complying with certain provisions of the HIPAA Rules, and a natural person can be one. It says business associates must notify covered entities if a breach occurs at or by the business associate (HHS Breach Notification Rule). Agree in the contract how a freelancer reports an incident to you, and how fast.

Freelancer vs company at a glance

FactorFreelancerHealthcare software development company
Cost structureA rate may cover one person’s time. The IRS calls correct worker classification critical. Verify it with tax advice.A quote may bundle roles such as QA, project management, and DevOps. Verify which roles and which hours the quote includes.
PHI and BAAA natural person can be a business associate, and a subcontractor who handles PHI for them needs a BAA too. Verify who else touches the work.A company that handles PHI for you needs a BAA, and so do its subcontractors. Verify the subcontractor list.
Control and IPOwnership starts with the person who wrote the code unless work-for-hire conditions are met. Verify signed assignment terms.Commissioned work from an independent contractor follows the same four conditions. A company’s own employees’ work belongs to the company, so ownership reaches you by contract. Verify signed assignment terms and repository access.
ContinuityIf the one person leaves, nobody else may hold the knowledge. Verify documentation and credential handover.If the contract names no replacement process, a departure still disrupts the work. Verify replacement and handover terms.
Ramp-up timeAsk for a start date in writing and confirm the person’s current workload.Ask for a start date in writing and confirm which people are available.
Compliance workIf PHI lands on a freelancer’s own devices, those devices are part of the risk. Verify devices, encryption, and incident reporting.If you are a covered entity or business associate, your ePHI stays subject to the Security Rule whoever builds the software. Verify the company’s policies against your risk analysis.
When this option is the right choiceA small, well-defined task, a narrow skill, or work with no PHI, and a person you trust to sign and follow a BAA.PHI, several roles, a long roadmap, or a need for one accountable party.

When TATEEDA is the wrong choice

  • You want a specific independent engineer. TATEEDA’s healthcare page says it does not rely on freelancers or gig workers.
  • You need a few hours of narrow expertise or a one-off review. A freelancer or consultant, with a BAA if PHI is involved, may be quicker to engage.
  • Your prototype uses synthetic data only and the budget is small. A freelancer may be enough for that stage.
  • You need engineers in your building. TATEEDA is headquartered in San Diego. We work with US-managed nearshore teams in Latin America and engineers in Europe.
  • You already know someone from your own network who has healthcare references and will sign a BAA.
  • Your deciding factor is the lowest rate. Compare several quotes on the same scope, and note that we do not claim to be the cheapest.

We cover two related decisions in our posts on in-house vs outsourced healthcare software development and offshore vs US-managed nearshore teams.

FAQ

If the freelancer creates, receives, maintains, or transmits PHI on your behalf, that matches HHS’s description of a business associate, and the covered entity needs satisfactory assurances in a contract or other written arrangement. If you are yourself a business associate, the freelancer is your subcontractor and needs a BAA with you. If the work uses only synthetic data that contains no PHI, the definition may not apply, and counsel should confirm.


It depends on the facts. HHS’s definition of a business associate excludes workforce members, and the regulations describe workforce as people whose conduct is under your direct control. Ask counsel to classify each individual.


If the freelancer is an independent contractor, the code is not a work made for hire unless a signed written agreement meets the Copyright Office conditions for commissioned work, including one of nine eligible categories. A person who is legally an employee acting within the scope of employment is treated differently. Whether a freelancer is an employee depends on the facts, so ask counsel. Without a work-made-for-hire arrangement, the author is ordinarily the person who wrote it. Counsel can draft assignment terms that put ownership where you want it.


No. HHS says all ePHI created, received, maintained, or transmitted by an organization (a covered entity or business associate) is subject to the Security Rule. The vendor’s BAA must require the vendor to follow the Security Rule and report incidents. Your own risk analysis remains yours.


Ask whether they will sign a BAA, who else will touch the work, which tools and cloud accounts will hold PHI, which devices they use, and how they would report an incident. HHS says business associates must notify covered entities if a breach occurs at or by the business associate.


If you are weighing these options for a specific build, we can review scope, PHI exposure, and team shape with you. Get a project-fit assessment.

About the author

Slava Khristich

CTO at TATEEDA | GLOBAL

Slava Khristich is the Chief Technology Officer of TATEEDA | GLOBAL, a San Diego-based custom software development company founded in 2013. He leads engineering for healthcare organizations, medical practices, and health-tech startups building HIPAA-compliant systems: EHR and EMR integrations, patient portals, telehealth platforms, medical billing…

Contact us to start

We normally respond within 24 hours

If you need immediate attention, please give us
a call at +1 (619) 630-7568

Use our free estimator to find out your
approximate cost.

We reply within 24 hours, and the first call is with the CTO, not a salesperson.