Staff Augmentation vs Managed Services: What Are the Key Differences?
Vlad Nazarov
This article compares IT staff augmentation vs managed services to determine which option best suits your company or project. If you’re not a seasoned CTO or CEO, choosing between IT staff augmentation and managed services can present challenges. This guide aims to help you make an informed strategic decision.
? Recent studies highlight a global challenge: approximately 80% of employers reported difficulties in finding skilled talent in 2023, with the issue affecting 75% of employers in the United States. In industries like financial services and high tech, 87% of respondents anticipate skill gaps affecting their operations in the near future.
With increased skill shortages on the horizon, many companies are adopting a variety of strategies to address these gaps. This includes leveraging the difference between managed services and IT staff augmentation to ensure they have the necessary skills and resources to continue their businesses effectively.
Approximately 60% of companies plan to address their skill gaps and talent shortages by offering their workforce more flexible scheduling options, such as part-time work and flexible hours.
Additionally, these companies are outsourcing tech services, tasks, projects, or entire departments to remote teams, including nearshore, offshore, or hybrid models. This approach is primarily applied to IT consulting, custom software development, digital marketing, and various engineering professions.
If you’re still unsure about the basic differences between the two models, here’s a concise comparison of IT staff augmentation vs. managed services:
| IT Staff Augmentation | Managed Services |
| An approach where you temporarily fill skill gaps with professionals provided by a vendor, typically on a short-term basis but sometimes longer if needed. You manage these professionals directly, integrating them into your team. | A method where an external provider completely handles specific IT functions, offering a hands-off approach for you. The provider manages the entire service, from start to finish. |
| ⚠️ TATEEDA has a decade of experience in both IT staff augmentation and managed services, partnering with diverse IT professionals from over 16 countries. Our skilled U.S.-based project managers and remote developers ensure that projects are delivered on time, overcoming the IT outsourcing challenges of distance and time zone differences, and often saving clients more than 20% on product budgets. For instance, our remote team of over 60 developers and testers significantly enhances the capabilities of a major U.S.-based healthcare company. For an estimate or to learn more about our services, please contact us → |
Table of Contents
Explanation of the Outsourcing Models: Managed Services Model vs IT Staff Augmentation
Before we delve into the nuances that distinguish these two popular outsourcing concepts, let’s briefly review each one:
Staff Augmentation Overview
When choosing between IT staff augmentation and managed services, you might consider dealing with IT staff augmentation firms as a more flexible approach.
It’s utilized by businesses to temporarily enhance their existing workforce, adapting to project needs without long-term commitments. This model strategically employs onshore, nearshore application engineering, and offshore software development services to swiftly augment the capacity of in-house teams.
You can quickly extend your existing pool of IT skills and competencies by adding one or several specialists. Though augmented staff members are temporary, they integrate seamlessly, often accessing the same corporate resources as permanent employees.
Cost-effectiveness of Staff Augmentation: In comparing IT staff augmentation vs. managed services models, a primary advantage of the former is its cost-effectiveness. Businesses gain rapid access to essential skills and expand their team’s capabilities without the significant financial outlay required for permanent hires or the risks entailed by signing long-term contracts with remote vendors.
Managed Services Overview
Managed services entail outsourcing critical business functions to enhance operational efficiency. In this arrangement, a managed service provider (MSP) functions like an internal employee but operates independently. Once project terms and budget are approved, the MSP diligently manages tasks, ensuring regular updates and interactions with the client.
Operational Benefits of Managed Services: Managed services are prized for enhancing operational efficiency and streamlining resource management, enabling companies to concentrate on their primary business functions.
By delegating intricate tasks such as AWS cloud database monitoring or complex Azure-backed software development, businesses gain access to specialized expertise and reduce the burden of maintaining large internal teams. This approach optimizes operations, accelerates project timelines, and improves service quality.
Key Differences Between Managed Services and IT Staff Augmentation Models
Understanding the difference between IT staff augmentation and managed services is crucial for organizations looking to enhance their IT capabilities effectively.
Each model offers distinct advantages and caters to different business needs, from project scope and management to cost considerations and team integration.
Below is a comparison table that outlines the key differences between these two popular outsourcing strategies:
| Criteria | IT Staff Augmentation | Managed Services |
| Scope of Work | Specific tasks or projects | Comprehensive management of entire functions or processes |
| Control & Management | Client retains direct control and management over the staff | Provider manages the service independently with oversight from the client |
| Cost Structure | Often variable based on the hours worked or duration of engagement | Typically a fixed-cost or subscription model providing predictable budgeting |
| Flexibility | High, with the ability to scale team sizes up or down quickly | Less flexible; changes may require contract renegotiations |
| Skill Set | Targeted to specific needs, filling precise skill gaps | Broad and comprehensive, covering a wide range of skills |
| Duration of Engagement | Usually short-term or project-based, can be extended as needed | Long-term engagement, with ongoing responsibilities |
| Responsibility for Outcomes | Client is primarily responsible for the project outcomes | Provider is responsible for delivering specified outcomes within agreed parameters |
| Integration with Existing Teams | Seamless integration, works as part of the client’s in-house team | May operate more independently, with less integration into client’s existing teams |
Advantages and Disadvantages of Both Outsourcing Concepts
In exploring the difference between managed services and IT staff augmentation approaches, it’s crucial to understand the distinct advantages and disadvantages of each to determine the best fit for your organizational needs.
Both models offer unique benefits and can be instrumental depending on your project requirements, budget constraints, control preferences, and the latest IT outsourcing trends.
Here’s a closer comparison of these two models to help you navigate your options:
| Model | Pros | Cons |
| Staff Augmentation | – Greater control over the team – Immediate access to specific skills – Flexible adjustment of team size | – Dependence on the availability of talent – Potentially higher costs for extended periods |
| Managed Services | – Comprehensive outsourcing solution – Predictable costs for easier budgeting – Allows focus on core business activities | – Reduced control over daily tasks – Contracts may lack flexibility, leading to long-term commitments |
Are You Still Unsure Which IT Outsourcing Model to Choose?
Schedule a free consultation with one of our IT experts to receive tailored guidance and an estimate for your project.
Decision Factors: When to Use Each Model
When choosing between different outsourcing models, it’s vital to consider the specific circumstances and goals of your organization.
Here, we delve into the scenarios that best suit each model, helping you determine the most effective strategy for your needs.
When to Use Staff Augmentation
Staff augmentation is most beneficial when:
- Specific Skill Requirements: Your project requires specialized technical skills that your current team lacks, let’s say .NET development talents, and these are needed temporarily to complement your existing capabilities.
- Peak Load Management: There’s a need to handle increased workload during peak times without the commitment to long-term hires.
- Project Flexibility: You seek to maintain control over the project management while quickly scaling team size up or down based on the project phase or demand.
This model offers agility and control, making it ideal for projects with dynamic requirements or when you wish to keep strategic functions in-house.
When to Use Managed Services
Managed services are the preferred option when:
- Ongoing Needs: Your organization requires continuous management of certain IT functions or operations that are complex and resource-intensive, like remote DevOps consulting and services.
- Cost Management: You prefer a predictable cost model that simplifies budgeting for IT services without the fluctuations associated with ad hoc problem-solving.
- Focus on Core Business: There’s a strategic decision to focus on core business functions without being bogged down by the day-to-day management of IT operations.
This model is particularly useful for companies looking to offload routine or specialized IT tasks to focus more on strategic growth and core business outcomes.
| Outsourcing Model | Ideal Scenarios |
| Staff Augmentation | – Short-term projects needing specific skills. – Projects with fluctuating workloads requiring rapid scaling. – Situations where direct control over work and staff is desired. |
| Managed Services | – Long-term, continuous IT functions needing management. – Situations where predictable budgeting is crucial. – When the goal is to minimize involvement in daily IT operations to focus on core business strategies. |
Practical Examples of IT Staff Augmentation and Managed Services
These real-world applications illuminate the differences and situational advantages of each model within the framework of IT staff augmentation vs managed services, helping companies like VROM Automation and Visiontree achieve specific, strategic outcomes tailored to their unique needs.
Managed Services Example: VROM Automation
For managed services, consider the case of VROM Automation. Seeking to upgrade their in-house warehouse management system, they partnered with TATEEDA GLOBAL to develop a custom, web-based platform integrated with eBay.
This solution significantly improved their e-commerce inventory and sales processes, offering extensive inventory and warehouse management optimized for IoT networks and industrial automation.
The team’s efforts included designers and developers skilled in .NET and Angular, who collectively enhanced the system’s efficiency and transparency.
IT Staff Augmentation Example: Visiontree
In the realm of IT staff augmentation, Visiontree exemplifies its utility. Visiontree, a leader in cloud-based patient management systems, needed specialized talent to deliver high-quality electronic data capture (EDC) forms to healthcare organizations across the U.S.
TATEEDA GLOBAL provided a team consisting of a lead developer, HTML front-end developer, two Vue.js developers, manual QA engineers, and UI/UX design assistance.
This augmentation allowed Visiontree to ensure timely, secure, and effective data collection and analysis in patient care and research.
Key Factors to Consider Before Choosing an Outsourcing Model
When deciding on the most suitable outsourcing model for your company, it is crucial to thoroughly assess various factors to determine whether IT staff augmentation or managed services best aligns with your needs:
- Project Scope: Consider the specific requirements and duration of your project.
For short-term projects needing specialized skills temporarily, IT staff augmentation is often ideal, as it allows you to flexibly add expertise to your team.
For ongoing projects requiring comprehensive management of IT functions, managed services provide a stable, long-term solution.
- Internal Capabilities: Evaluate your in-house team’s current capabilities and capacity.
If you need to quickly fill skill gaps without expanding permanent headcount, IT staff augmentation can provide the necessary expertise on demand.
If your project demands continuous and broad-ranging IT support that your internal team can’t provide, consider managed services for complete outsourcing.
- Budget Constraints: Determine your financial flexibility for outsourcing.
IT staff augmentation can be cost-effective for controlling operational costs as you pay only for the skills you need when you need them.
Managed services, while potentially requiring a higher initial investment, can offer predictable costing and reduce long-term operational expenses.
- Strategic Goals: Align the outsourcing model with your long-term objectives.
If enhancing agility and scaling rapidly according to project demands aligns with your strategic goals, IT staff augmentation provides the flexibility to adapt quickly.
If your strategy involves offloading routine or complex IT operations to focus more on core business activities, managed services might be the better route, ensuring all IT needs are comprehensively managed by an external provider.
Learn more: ➡️ How to Select Healthcare Software Developers in the U.S.
Making the Right Choice with TATEEDA: Staff Augmentation vs. Managed Services
In this discussion, we’ve explored the vital distinctions between IT staff augmentation and managed services, emphasizing their unique advantages and suitable scenarios. Choosing the right model depends heavily on your specific project requirements, resource availability, and strategic objectives.
If you’re ready to enhance your company’s operational capacity or need dedicated expertise for your IT projects, consider partnering with TATEEDA GLOBAL.
We offer tailored solutions in both staff augmentation and managed services to fit your business needs perfectly. Assess your company’s requirements and let us help you determine the most effective approach to achieve your goals.
? Contact TATEEDA GLOBAL today to explore our services and discover how we can support your business’s growth and innovation.
